Controlling scope: a key to indoctrination

A year or so after I became an atheist, I started taking a casual interest in philosophy, especially meta-ethics. Over this time, it has often struck me how much wider the scope of philosophy is, compared to theology. Philosophy asks obscenely general questions. How do I know anything? Is there a right way to approach morality? What do “good” and “bad” actually mean?

I wonder, then, if religious indoctrination works so well because it gives a false sense of permissiveness: it allows its subjects to ask quite a wide range of probing questions, as long as they don’t verge on broader, meta-religious issues.

Throughout my (rather liberal) Christian experience, I encountered little resistance to my curiosity about religious issues, yet this curiosity somehow never extended to the really big, general questions like those of philosophy. I never once wondered what “good” and “bad” really meant. I never even questioned the existence of God.

Instead, my religious conditioning led me (even encouraged me) to ask only the narrower questions: What does God want me to do? What did Jesus mean when he said this? I was completely unaware, at the time, that there even existed more general questions as these: I had been taught that God and his teachings encompassed everything. This false sense of scope eclipsed a much broader arena of thought.

For this reason, I suspect that if I had been exposed to philosophy at a younger age, I would have shone the light of critical thought on my religious beliefs much earlier. Perhaps this ought to be a goal of those who would seek to broaden the horizons of the indoctrinated.



2 Responses to Controlling scope: a key to indoctrination

  1. Chris says:

    My dad was brought up christian (type- I dunno šŸ˜‰ he went in the military to fund college and so was a bit older (re. more mature) than the average student- he then proceded to major in Philosophy and Religion- and as he put it- educated himself right out of belief. I then had the wonderful opportunity to be raised as an atheist. We had a small amount of religious exposure and a lot of family discussion.. applying logic to life ??s generally leads people of honesty to atheism.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: